• Home
  • About
  • Defense Systems
  • Manufacturer
  • Comparisons
  • Compare 
  • Tools
TheDefenseWatch.com
  • Aerospace & Aviation
  • Military & Ordnance
  • Naval & Maritime
  • Cyber & Space Defense
  • Policy & Strategy
  • Global News
  • Tools Library
    • Smart Calculator
    • Drone Flight Time Calculator
    • Drone Range Calculator
    • Counter-Drone Jammer Effective Range Calculator
    • Counter-Battery Radar Detection Calculator
    • Artillery Fire Correction Calculator
    • Thermal Camera Detection Range Calculator
    • Missile Range & Time-of-Flight Calculator
    • Radar Detection Range Calculator
    • FPV Strike Drone Payload vs Range Calculator
    • Loitering Munition Endurance Calculator
    • Sniper Ballistic Drop & Windage Calculator
    • Bullet Drop Calculator
    • U.S. Army Combat Fitness Test (ACFT) Calculator
    • Military Pension Calculator
    • Military Retirement Calculator
    • Military Pension Calculator
    • Large Number Calculator
Font ResizerAa

TheDefenseWatch.com

The Defense Watch | U.S. & Global Defense News, Analysis & Military Updates

Search
  • Home
  • About
  • Defense Systems
  • Manufacturer
  • Comparisons
  • Compare 
  • Tools

Stay Updated

Get the latest update

Subscribe

Explore

  • Drone
  • Fighter Jets & Military Aircraft
  • Hypersonic Weapons
  • Aircraft Carriers
  • Strategic History & Missions
  • Tools Library
Home » Chinese Defence Analyst Counters Claim That Indian Air Force Is Superior to Chinese Air Force
Global News

Chinese Defence Analyst Counters Claim That Indian Air Force Is Superior to Chinese Air Force

TeamDefenseWatch
Last updated: October 21, 2025 9:10 am
TeamDefenseWatch
Share
2 Min Read
Indian Air Force
SHARE
Follow The Defense Watch on Google:

A noted Chinese defence analyst has publicly criticised recent assessments claiming that the Indian Air Force (IAF) now surpasses the People’s Liberation Army Air Force (PLAAF) in overall capability. The comments come after the World Directory of Modern Military Aircraft (WDMMA) ranking placed India third globally—with a TruVal Rating (TVR) of 69.4, ahead of China at 63.8. In Beijing, the reaction has been dismissive of the ranking and sceptical of the underlying methodology.

Background
According to the WDMMA ranking, the IAF—which operates approximately 1,716 aircraft—scored higher than the PLAAF in the TVR, despite China’s larger overall inventory. The TVR metric takes into account not just fleet size but also aircraft mix, logistics, modernization, training and domestic aerospace-industry capability. Chinese media outlets, including state-affiliated commentary, have challenged the validity of the ranking and suggested that “paper rankings” do not equate to actual combat capability.

Details of the Reaction
In an article titled “Why China Is Rattled at India’s Rise in Global Air Power Rankings”, defence-industry commentator Ravi Shankar noted that Beijing’s annoyance reflects the erosion of the PLAAF’s self-image as Asia’s air-power benchmark. Chinese official commentary described the ranking as “meaningless” and cautioned that such comparisons may lead to “dangerous miscalculations”. The crux of the critique is that while the IAF may present strength in balance and modernization, this does not necessarily translate into direct superiority in a scenario involving the PLAAF’s larger fleet, advanced platforms and integrated systems.

One Chinese analyst stated that: “Militaries should be assessed on real combat performance rather than paper strength.” This aligns with broader Chinese commentary that emphasizes operational experience, tested systems and integrated networked warfare over statistical indices.

- Advertisement -

Meanwhile, the WDMMA data underpinning the claim highlights that although China possesses a larger total number of military aircraft (5,357) compared with India’s 2,488 across services, the IAF’s strength in component balance boosted its TVR. Specifically, India’s mix — roughly 31.6 % fighters, 29 % helicopters and 21.8 % trainers — was cited as evidence of a more balanced air-force structure. In contrast, China’s proportion of fighters was higher, but its fleet reportedly showed less balance in special-mission, training and transport assets.

Expert/Policy Perspective
From a strategic perspective, the Chinese reaction underscores concerns in Beijing that an elevated Indian air-power ranking may shift regional perceptions and influence coalition building in the Indo-Pacific. As one policy observer noted, placing India ahead of China in air-force rankings “suggests a recalibration in Asia’s balance of air power”.

Another viewpoint emphasises that such rankings, while useful for external audiences, must be treated with caution. According to the WDMMA itself, unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) are currently not fully accounted for in its methodology — a potential limitation especially given China’s significant UAV development. Therefore, analysts in Beijing argue that the PLAAF’s broader integration with unmanned assets, long-range strike systems and networked command and control may not be fully reflected in the TVR.

In New Delhi, Indian officials have welcomed recognition of the IAF’s progress but emphasised the need to continue modernization, increase squadron strength and develop indigenous platforms. Analysts in India stress that surpassing China in rankings does not remove the need for further capability expansion and readiness.

Impact and What’s Next
The Chinese defence analyst’s commentary signals that even as New Delhi celebrates its rising air-power ranking, Beijing is carefully managing narrative and perception. The conversation is not simply about numeric ranking but about strategic signalling: a publicly elevated ranking for the IAF may influence procurement decisions, alliance flows and regional deterrence postures.

For India, the challenge remains to convert improved rankings into tangible operational readiness — maintaining squadron numbers, accelerating induction of new fighters, and expanding logistics and sustainment infrastructure. For China, the message is clear: Beijing will continue emphasising operational depth, integrated systems and combat-proven capabilities rather than relying solely on rankings.

In the broader regional context, this development may drive both countries to accelerate modernization, sharpen training, and invest more heavily in next-generation air-power assets and allied interoperability. Observers will watch closely whether the IAF can maintain momentum and whether the PLAAF responds with visible shifts to modernisation, force posture or public assessments of capability.

Source

- Advertisement -

Enjoying our coverage?

Make The Defense Watch a preferred source on Google to see more of our geopolitical and defense insights when relevant to you.

TAGGED:air power rankingAsia-Pacific defenceChinese Air ForceIndian Air ForceMilitary Aviation
Share This Article
Facebook Copy Link Print
ByTeamDefenseWatch
TeamDefenseWatch is the official editorial byline of TheDefenseWatch.com. Working under one umbrella, TheDefenseWatch.com, the team delivers verified, factual reporting on global defense, military technology, aerospace systems, and security developments. Articles are sourced from official statements, defense industry releases, and trusted media, with editorial review to ensure accuracy and clarity.Contact: info@TheDefenseWtach.com
6 Comments
  • Pingback: India’s HAL Reaches 50 % Readiness for Su-57E Stealth Fighter Production
  • Pingback: India Inaugurates Nyoma Air Base in Ladakh, Boosting High-Altitude Airpower Near LAC
  • Pingback: Trump Signals Decision on Possible Military Action in Venezuela Amid “Operation Southern Spear” Deployment
  • Pingback: Two U.S. Soldiers, Civilian Interpreter Killed in Syria Ambush | TheDefenseWatch.com
  • Pingback: NATO Chief Rutte Says Europe Can’t Defend Itself Without U.S, Emphasizes Continued Ukraine Support | TheDefenseWatch.com
  • Pingback: Iran Releases Footage of Khorramshahr-4 Missile, Tehran Calls Operational | TheDefenseWatch.com

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search Defense Systems

Latest Defense Systems

  • F-15J Eagle Fighter Jet F-15J Eagle Fighter Jet
  • China’s GJ-21 Stealth Drone China’s GJ-21 Stealth Drone
  • China’s GJ-11 Stealth Drone China’s GJ-11 Stealth Drone
  • F-15EX Eagle Fighter Jet F-15EX Eagle Fighter Jet
  • TRML-4D Radar TRML-4D Radar
  • F-47A Fighter Jet F-47A Fighter Jet
  • China DF-61 Missile China DF-61 Missile
  • B61 Nuclear Bomb B61 Nuclear Bomb
  • Japan E-767 Airborne Japan E-767 Airborne

Recent Compares

  • J-10C vs JF-17 Thunder: Which Fighter Is More Capable? J-10C vs JF-17 Thunder: Which Fighter Is More Capable? View Comparison →
  • Tejas vs Gripen: Key Differences and Capabilities Tejas vs Gripen: Key Differences and Capabilities View Comparison →
  • Tejas vs MiG-21 Bison: How India Replaced Its Iconic Supersonic Fighter Tejas vs MiG-21 Bison: How India Replaced Its Iconic Supersonic Fighter View Comparison →
  • F-35 vs F-16: Stealth, Sensors and Combat Roles F-35 vs F-16: Stealth, Sensors and Combat Roles View Comparison →
  • Tejas Fighter Jet vs F-16 Fighting Falcon: Capability Compared Tejas Fighter Jet vs F-16 Fighting Falcon: Capability Compared View Comparison →
  • Rafale Fighter Jet vs F-16 Fighting Falcon : Which Fighter Has the Edge? Rafale Fighter Jet vs F-16 Fighting Falcon : Which Fighter Has the Edge? View Comparison →
  • Su-57 Fighter Jet vs J-20 Fighter Jet: Stealth and Air Combat Compared Su-57 Fighter Jet vs J-20 Fighter Jet: Stealth and Air Combat Compared View Comparison →
  • Mirage 2000 vs Tejas Mk1A: Legacy Combat Power vs Indigenous Modernization Mirage 2000 vs Tejas Mk1A: Legacy Combat Power vs Indigenous Modernization View Comparison →
  • Rafale Fighter Jet vs F-22 Raptor: Which Air Dominance Fighter Has the Edge? Rafale Fighter Jet vs F-22 Raptor: Which Air Dominance Fighter Has the Edge? View Comparison →
  • Tejas Fighter Jet vs. Rafale Fighter Jet: India’s Indigenous Fighter Meets France’s Proven Multirole Combat Aircraft Tejas Fighter Jet vs. Rafale Fighter Jet: India’s Indigenous Fighter Meets France’s Proven Multirole Combat Aircraft View Comparison →

Recent Posts

  • Meta Muse AI Agent Faces Privacy Concerns After Reports of Unauthorized Data Access
  • Trump Nominates Christopher LaNeve for Permanent U.S. Army Chief of Staff
  • Sweden and UK Plan Meteor Missile Support for Ukraine’s Gripen Fighters
  • Collins Aerospace Breaks Ground on Propeller MRO Facility in India
  • Northrop Grumman Tests M-ACE System With 30mm Bushmaster Against Drones

You Might Also Like

US Canada airspace warning
Global News

US Warns It Could Send Fighter Jets Into Canadian Airspace if F-35 Deal Collapses

September 7, 2026
China J-10CE combat success
Asian Defense & Security

China Confirms First Combat Kill for J-10CE Fighter in 2025 India-Pakistan War

January 15, 2026
JIATF-401 counter-drone system
Global News

Pentagon’s JIATF-401 Picks Bumblebee V2 Kinetic Counter-Drone System To Boost Warfighter Lethality

September 7, 2026
Piorun MANPADS Germany
Global News

Germany Eyes Piorun MANPADS Acquisition To Counter Drone Threat

September 8, 2026

Logo

Copyright © 2026 TheDefenseWatch.com

Helpful Links

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use / Disclaimer
  • U.S. Privacy Notice – CCPA Compliance

Defense Systems

  • Defense Systems
  • Comparisons 
  • Manufacturer
  • Tactical Calculators

Popuplar

Which 5 Air Forces Possess the Costliest Fighter Jet Fleets in the World
Evolving Strategic Value: Carrier Strike Groups in the Indo-Pacific’s Future Security Architecture
Autonomous Weapon Systems Spark U.S. Ethics Debate Amid Rapid Military AI Integration

We report on developments involving military forces, governments, defense companies, research organizations, and security institutions around the world. 

Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?

Enjoying our coverage?

Make The Defense Watch a preferred source on Google to see more insights.